The time machine
The mountains are payments, month by month.
Before the nameNovember 2014
“Yeah, yeah, cool”The Oro Stube, as Amadori tells it
This month's fact
The pizzeria in Povo
A researcher asks the Oro Stube, near his research centre, whether it would like to accept bitcoin. He asks half in jest. The first payments date from this month.
In the chronicle → Amadori, interviews and testimony
The ledger begins on 25 July 2015: here there are the price and the facts.
- payments
- –
- active accounts
- –
- one bitcoin
- €293
- sat, a coffee
- 410,245
Three months with a voice
The barman
0:21“But then at some point, what happened? A barman in Rovereto, way back in two-thousand-and-something, when bitcoin reached 2,000 euros, so you can work out when it was by looking at the market, decided to celebrate by giving a discount of no less than 25% on everything paid for in bitcoin.”
A real place
0:14“The Bitcoin Valley is a place, a real place, in the north of Italy, mainly in Trentino. It's the place with the highest density of businesses that accept Bitcoin per inhabitant.”
The mirror
0:10“We could probably have earned 10%, maybe more, by dealing in other rubbish as well. But I wouldn't have been able to look at myself in the mirror in the morning.”
How to read it
Each point on the ridge is a month: in front the payments at the till, on a square-root scale, with Lightning in yellow; behind, in a lighter tone and on a scale of its own, the active accounts. The red dots are the facts in the chronicle. The sun is the price of bitcoin, the month's average in euros, on a logarithmic scale. The coffee costs €1.20, at that average price.
The ledger begins on 25 July 2015 and sees only the customers of our own system: those who made their own arrangements don't appear, nor do the first payments of 2014 and the first with Lightning. Prices: monthly averages from blockchain.info and ECB exchange rates. It also moves with the arrow keys; Page Up and Page Down jump a year. The full chronicle, with its notes, is the text all this comes from.
All the facts, in order
| When | What | Payments | One bitcoin | A coffee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 2014 | The pizzeria in Povo. A researcher asks the Oro Stube, near his research centre, whether it would like to accept bitcoin. He asks half in jest. The first payments date from this month. | – | €293 | 410,245 sat |
| Late 2014 | First time on television. Amadori goes on television for the first time, with Messora, on byoblu. Bitcoin is worth around €300. They will be back eleven years later. | – | €279 | 430,115 sat |
| January 2015 | A beer at the Mani al Cielo. On 28 January, in Rovereto, Marco Amadori pays Gianpaolo Rossi, the owner, for a beer in bitcoin. Nine days earlier L'Adige has written about him. | – | €217 | 553,514 sat |
| April 2015 | Would it suit a hotel?. Confcommercio Trentino, the traders' association, asks shopkeepers whether a bitcoin payment system would be worth adopting too. | – | €218 | 549,473 sat |
| May 2015 | The first commit. On 1 May the software for merchants begins, on the 3rd inbitcoin.it is registered, on the 14th Beba arrives, who will work on it for ten years. There is no company yet. | – | €212 | 566,327 sat |
| July 2015 | The ledger begins. The first payment in the ledger is dated 25 July 2015. From here on the mountains are real payments, month by month. | 28 | €253 | 473,395 sat |
| November 2015 | The comic shop in Pordenone. In Torre, at Via Piave 26, a comic shop, a sandwich bar and a publisher start taking bitcoin. Within a week they are in three local papers. | 4 | €323 | 372,073 sat |
| December 2015 | Italian capital of bitcoin. The press counts 18 outlets in Rovereto, for fewer than 40,000 inhabitants, against 32 in Milan and 22 in Rome. | 1 | €388 | 309,359 sat |
| May 2016 | The run begins. From this month on no month will be left empty: not April 2020, not January 2023. The run reaches 126 months in a row. | 3 | €405 | 296,185 sat |
| June 2016 | inbitcoin is founded. Eighteen shareholders and an office in Milan. Everyone else is calling their startups blockchain: they choose inbitcoin. | 8 | €567 | 211,524 sat |
| July 2016 | A beer by QR code. Trento Today writes about the Trentino startup building digital-money services: you can buy a beer before you even walk into the bar. | 12 | €598 | 200,733 sat |
| September 2016 | Tim, Apple and the Forst beer hall. In Trento you can pay at the Tim store in Piazza Duomo, at the Apple Premium Reseller and for lunch at the Forst beer hall. In Rovereto the bar too, during futsal matches. | 35 | €538 | 223,243 sat |
| October 2016 | Fourteen doors. inbitcoin's flyer lists fourteen places to pay, seven in Rovereto and seven in and around Trento. Seven still have an entry on the map. | 38 | €578 | 207,504 sat |
| November 2016 | The salary at the bar. The developers are paid in bitcoin and spend it with the wallet they write, called Altana from this month, in the bar running the POS they write. | 46 | €669 | 179,339 sat |
| December 2016 | The name. On 19 December, in a translation file for the website, it appears for the first time in a dated document. “Bitcoin Valley” will follow on 12 January. | 39 | €776 | 154,655 sat |
| Early 2017 | Da Papi. Ivan, of the Da Papi pizzeria, starts accepting bitcoin and keeps most of what he takes. A bitcoin is worth just under €850. | 42 | €858 | 139,862 sat |
| February 2017 | The motion is tabled. On 28 February councillor Alessio Manica tables proposal no. 542 at the Province. It will become motion no. 174. | 78 | €993 | 120,869 sat |
| March 2017 | Rossi does the sums. il Dolomiti writes about the Valley: at the Mani al Cielo one employee takes her entire salary in bitcoin. | 77 | €1,059 | 113,323 sat |
| May 2017 | The biggest demo in the world. Between April 2017 and November 2018 Nicola Vaccari gives sixteen of the talks whose slides survive. The full tour comes to 47 meetings in 26 cities. | 75 | €1,667 | 71,968 sat |
| In 2017, at €2,000 | 25% off to celebrate. Bitcoin reaches €2,000 and the barman at the Mani al Cielo celebrates with 25% off. They tell him it's too much. There is a bitcoin ATM on the premises too, and a few customers work out the trick. | 66 | €2,331 | 51,491 sat |
| July 2017 | School meals make the paper. L'Adige of 23 July, page 33: school meals to be paid for in bitcoin. | 92 | €2,167 | 55,373 sat |
| August 2017 | The network splits. Those who want bigger blocks leave with another coin, and SegWit activates. The people who were wrong, says Amadori, financed the people who were right. | 112 | €3,229 | 37,169 sat |
| September 2017 | Canteens for 11,107 pupils. The Comunità della Vallagarina writes to parents that canteen accounts can be topped up in bitcoin: about 900,000 meal vouchers a year. For il Dolomiti it is the first public service in Italy payable this way. | 111 | €3,436 | 34,923 sat |
| October 2017 | Panorama's cover. On 26 October the weekly Panorama puts Bitcoin on its cover and gives a page to “Rovereto, the Bit Valley”. | 136 | €4,496 | 26,688 sat |
| November 2017 | Motion no. 174. On 7 November Trento's provincial council passes it: one vote against, four abstentions. It is also the ledger's summit, 139 payments in a month. | 139 | €6,514 | 18,422 sat |
| December 2017 | The Via Rialto shop. On 5 December Wired describes the first shop in Italy you can walk into to buy bitcoin: Comproeuro, in Rovereto. Meanwhile the network is clogged. | 132 | €12,540 | 9,569 sat |
| January 2018 | Sixty, after a hundred and thirty-two. The shop has opened with the network clogged: in January the ledger shows fewer than half of December's payments, and meanwhile the price is falling. The lesson comes right away. | 60 | €10,709 | 11,206 sat |
| February 2018 | The Valley goes to Parliament. On 14 February, at Palazzo San Macuto, Amadori, Sannino and Vaccari describe staff and suppliers paid in bitcoin. The Le Iene report bears the same date. | 74 | €7,604 | 15,782 sat |
| March 2018 | Real Users. On 16 March Bitcoin Magazine publishes Aaron van Wirdum's report. It opens inside Comproeuro: a man has driven 80 kilometres and is feeding 50-euro notes into the ATM. | 78 | €7,387 | 16,244 sat |
| April 2018 | The second Comproeuro. On 7 April, at Corso Vittorio Emanuele 23 in Pordenone, the ribbon is cut at 18:00. Lignano Pineta and Bologna will follow. | 66 | €6,491 | 18,487 sat |
| February-May 2018 | An anthropologist in Rovereto. Between February and May Giovanni Daniele Starita, a student at Utrecht, studies the Valley in the field. His first conversation with Amadori requires “the consumption of several beers”. | 98 | €7,167 | 16,743 sat |
| June 2018 | Lightning at the bar. At the start of June inbitcoin switches on its first Lightning node at the Mani al Cielo. The RGB developers pay from the garden, each with a different wallet. | 102 | €5,832 | 20,577 sat |
| July 2018 | In front of the sceptics. Amadori and Giacomo Zucco are guests of High on Subversion at Fabrica, the centre run by Oliviero Toscani, before an audience of sceptics and the curious. | 117 | €6,070 | 19,769 sat |
| August 2018 | Dead 307 times. On 15 August Il Fatto Quotidiano writes about those who remain in Rovereto. The day before, a bitcoin has fallen to $5,960, and Bitcoin Obituaries has counted 307 death notices. | 50 | €5,806 | 20,670 sat |
| September 2018 | “Pagamento bitcoin”. On 14 September at the Mani al Cielo the receipt says “bitcoin payment”, with the rate of the moment. In Bologna the Viale Silvani shop opens, and the city declares itself Italy's first Bitcoin City. | 98 | €5,664 | 21,185 sat |
| October 2018 | Three talks in three days. On 24, 25 and 26 October: Bologna, Pordenone, Reggio Emilia. On the 3rd Bologna had its first inbitcoin transaction, at the Lime Bar. It is the year with the most active accounts: 48. | 117 | €5,650 | 21,238 sat |
| November 2018 | Terraforming. The project aims to make Bitcoin habitable: drinking, eating, paying the rent, filling up the car. In November inbitcoin publishes Starita's thesis. | 97 | €4,826 | 24,865 sat |
| December 2018 | Shop windows on Striscia. On 1 December the Valley's shop windows end up on Striscia la Notizia. The same month sees Lighter, inbitcoin's first open-source software. | 50 | €3,267 | 36,732 sat |
| January 2019 | At 19:15. Ten years after the genesis block, everyone is called to the Mani al Cielo to pull the cork at the exact hour of the first block. There are gatherings in fourteen other cities. | 43 | €3,232 | 37,125 sat |
| March 2019 | Technology in use. On 12 March inbitcoin sums itself up like this at Trentino Sviluppo: the Valley as a lab, and a team that uses what it writes. | 57 | €3,490 | 34,388 sat |
| In 2019 | Bitcoin Beach. In El Salvador Bitcoin Beach is born. In Rovereto, meanwhile, the ledger is already four years old. | 82 | €8,255 | 14,536 sat |
| Before Covid | From the audience. At an Economics Festival in Trento an expert explains from the stage that nobody uses cryptocurrencies. Someone raises a hand. | 58 | €7,558 | 15,878 sat |
| April 2020 | Two payments. Italy is shut indoors and the ledger shows two payments: few, but the month is not left empty. | 2 | €6,587 | 18,219 sat |
| 2020-21 | Lightning on trial. The Lightning POS is on trial at newsagents, bars, an ice-cream shop, a piadina bar, a hairdresser's and a restaurant. | 28 | €17,805 | 6,740 sat |
| After Covid | The startup ends. After Covid the developers' startup comes to an end: some are still working, others are taking it easy. | 24 | €28,436 | 4,220 sat |
| April 2021 | Le Iene, three years on. On 13 April Le Iene returns to Rovereto and asks what has changed most. People's attitude, they are told. | 8 | €47,832 | 2,509 sat |
| June 2021 | Legal tender, elsewhere. El Salvador makes it legal tender. At the Mani al Cielo in Rovereto people have been paying for six years. | 18 | €29,812 | 4,025 sat |
| Around 2021 | The canteens stop. Public-sector payments are centralised, and the region can no longer accept bitcoin without going through Rome. The exact date differs between interviews. | 44 | €28,947 | 4,145 sat |
| November 2021 | The city of Bitcoin. Rai's Re Start runs the headline “Rovereto, the city of Bitcoin”. | 16 | €53,336 | 2,250 sat |
| December 2021 | The first Lightning in the ledger. The first Lightning payment on record is dated 1 December 2021. Those of 2018 ran on systems since retired: the ledger has no trace of them. | 19 | €43,941 | 2,731 sat |
| March 2022 | Lugano's Plan ₿. On 3 March Bitcoin Magazine reports that Lugano will make Bitcoin legal tender. There it starts from the top, with the city council. Here it started at the counter. | 7 | €38,042 | 3,154 sat |
| June 2022 | In search of a problem. At TEDxBelluno Amadori recalls what his boss told him the first time he raised Bitcoin. | 8 | €23,389 | 5,131 sat |
| In 2022 | The low point. In 2022 there are sixteen active accounts and 126 payments, the lowest since 2016. | 4 | €16,016 | 7,492 sat |
| January 2023 | Just one. January 2023 shows one payment. It is the lowest month of the run, and the run does not break. | 1 | €18,594 | 6,454 sat |
| September 2023 | Coletti goes round Rovereto. Paolo Coletti pays with his phone in bars, shops, a tobacconist's and at the barber's. The month makes 56 payments, nearly all with Lightning. | 56 | €24,583 | 4,881 sat |
| March 2024 | Mount Lightning. 67 payments in a month, 65 with Lightning: the highest month since it arrived. A phone and a QR code are enough, and the typical bill is €13. | 67 | €62,016 | 1,935 sat |
| September 2024 | Farida Nabourema in the shop. On 7 September, a special opening: the Togolese activist comes to Via Rialto to talk about Bitcoin and human rights. | 37 | €54,182 | 2,215 sat |
| October 2024 | This is not bitcoin. A Comproeuro advertising page: a gold-coloured coin and, underneath, a question. Want to know why? | 38 | €59,958 | 2,001 sat |
| February 2025 | Cinco Días in Rovereto. The Spanish business daily runs a report on the town: 31 shops out of more than 950 in Italy according to Quibitcoin, the highest concentration in the country. | 22 | €92,096 | 1,303 sat |
| May 2025 | The old way. Amadori tells the line that measures the change: an ordinary shopkeeper calling the earlier way old. | 50 | €91,587 | 1,310 sat |
| September 2025 | Bitcoin at the arena. Comproeuro sponsors Olympia Rovereto, a futsal side in Serie A2 Élite, and from 27 September the bar at the PalaMarchetti arena takes bitcoin. | 34 | €96,352 | 1,245 sat |
| October 2025 | On stage. On 4 October “Bitcoin Economy” is at the Wired Next Fest, at Palazzo del Bene. On the 16th Amadori speaks to entrepreneurs and accountants at ImpAct, in Padua. | 41 | €98,160 | 1,222 sat |
| November 2025 | It holds nothing for anyone. The Via Rialto shop has never held anyone's euros or bitcoin. Amadori explains why with a joke. | 15 | €83,798 | 1,432 sat |
| December 2025 | Via Rialto stops changing. Because of the EU's MiCAR regulation the shop stops buying and selling directly, and until 27 November 2026 it gives out information. | 21 | €75,977 | 1,579 sat |
| April 2026 | Never buy them and never accept them!. A flyer lists accusations that turn out, at the end, to be aimed at another target. | 17 | €62,844 | 1,909 sat |
| May 2026 | Saturday 23. 38 of the month's 57 payments fall on a single day: the Pizza Day in Rimini. | 57 | €66,879 | 1,794 sat |
| July 2026 | The licence. From 1 July only holders of a MiCAR licence may provide bitcoin services, and the Via Rialto shop could not obtain one. In Rovereto, meanwhile, a café starts accepting bitcoin. | 15 | €55,807 | 2,150 sat |
| August 2026 | Closed for the patron saint. The shop puts up a notice, like any shop in town. | 19 | €59,487 | 2,017 sat |
| October 2026 | The ending is still to be written. A hundred and twenty-six months in a row with at least one payment at the till. In Rovereto people go on paying, nearly always with Lightning. | 13 | €73,753 | 1,627 sat |
The Valley, out loud The chronicle, with its notes All the ledger's numbers Said at the counter