Why altcoins get called that
The word was born in 2010, before the imitations even existed. Since then it has had quite a lot to tell.
A word from 2010
On 8 November 2010, on the bitcointalk forum, people are discussing who would launch a new chain to keep the easy coins of the early days. One user replies: if bitcoin catches on, imitators looking for easy money will turn up, “gitcoin, nitcoin, witcoin, titcoin, shitcoin…”, promising “51 shitcoins every 2 minutes”. They'll vanish soon, like the internet currencies of the nineties, but in the meantime “lots of people will get burned”.1
It is the first time we have found the word. Today it is the name the bitcoin community gives to the imitations, even in the rules of the Satoshi Spritz.2 In our slides of October 2016, in Trento and Rovereto, they were “scamcoins”.3 On 18 November 2016 Marco Amadori wrote the rule that still holds: “The 99 rule: if it isn't 99.99% Bitcoin it's a scam.”4
Coins that hand themselves out
Bitcoin was announced on a public mailing list, on 9 January 2009: the coins would go to the network's nodes “when they make blocks”, and to get some all you had to do was switch the program on.5 The first coin was created by whoever ran the program, on the same terms as everyone else.
Many imitations started the other way round: with a premine, coins created before launch and held by whoever wrote the project, or with an instamine, a launch in which whoever is there from the first moment takes a large share of the coins in a few hours.
Dash says it had no premine, and in the same document it tells of its launch: about 1.99 million coins in about 34 hours, because of an initial difficulty that was too low and an error in the reward. That was 10.5% of all the coins that will ever exist.6
Who holds the keys
Bitcoin has no administrator: there is nobody to ask to undo a payment or to stop the network.
On 17 June 2016, on the Ethereum network, an attack took away a part of The DAO's funds. On 20 July, at block 1,920,000, a fork changed the rules and gave the money back, as if the attack had never happened. A minority, for whom a blockchain must be immutable, stayed on the previous chain, today Ethereum Classic.7 For us it was a rollback: they went back and rewrote the chain's history.8
On 12 May 2022, while the Luna coin was collapsing, the validators of the Terra network halted the chain.9 A network that stops on command is a network with a command.
2017, a year of ICOs
ICOs are initial coin offerings, a way to raise money. On 25 July 2017 the SEC, the US securities regulator, concludes that The DAO's tokens are securities, and that whoever sells securities in the United States must register them.7 Block.one sells 900 million tokens between June 2017 and June 2018, raises several billion dollars without registering anything and in 2019 pays a 24 million penalty.10
According to a study from the time, over 80% of the ICO projects of 2017 had been identified as scams, and just three frauds took 11% of the money raised: 1.34 billion dollars out of 11.9.11
When there's a ruling
| Case | What the records say |
|---|---|
| Terra/Luna | On 5 April 2024 a jury finds Terraform Labs and its founder liable for fraud; the settlement with the SEC exceeds 4.5 billion dollars.12 According to the Department of Justice the 2022 collapse cost investors over 40 billion; the founder pleads guilty and is sentenced to 15 years on 11 December 2025.13 |
| OneCoin | Sold as the “Bitcoin killer”, it claimed to have a private blockchain and asked only to be trusted; its founder joins the FBI's Ten Most Wanted list on 30 June 2022.14 Between 2014 and 2016 it took in more than 4 billion dollars from at least 3.5 million victims, with a price set by the company that never went down. A lawyer who laundered its proceeds is sentenced to 10 years on 25 January 2024.15 |
| BitConnect | According to the Department of Justice, a Ponzi scheme: it promised guaranteed returns, paid the first investors with the money of the last ones and raised about 2.4 billion dollars. Its founder is indicted on 25 February 2022.16 According to the SEC it was 2 billion.17 An American promoter is sentenced to 38 months on 16 September 2022.18 |
The promises
“Like bitcoin, but better”, or even the “Bitcoin killer”. Our answer is in lesson 8, under “They'll make a better one”. The practical signal is in lesson 7: ask to try it with one euro.
Bitcoin, not blockchain
In 2016 others were calling their startups blockchain, and we chose inbitcoin. In Rovereto, that October, a slide said: “If there's no ‘bitcoin’ in it, it's a scam”, at least a semantic one: without bitcoin what's left is a distributed database, but a slow one, like an Intranet against the Internet in the nineties.19 In Trento, in 2018, the private blockchain was “dry water”: you can only sell it to someone who doesn't know what water is.20
How we handle them
At the Satoshi Spritz only Bitcoin is talked about: no altcoins, no tokens, no promotions.2 In our classroom lessons there were three tests: if it isn't bitcoin, it's a scam; if you can't have one euro of it on your phone, because it's sold in lots of 200 or 18,000 euros, it's a scam; if it's mining you can't see, it's fake cloud mining.19
If someone offers you a new coin, ask someone who doesn't gain from it. The other signals are in How not to get fleeced.
Lesson 8: the objections A story: the tulips All the lessons
-
bitcointalk, thread “Bitcoin is not as advertised”, message no. 103, 8 November 2010, 16:23 forum time: “gitcoin, nitcoin, witcoin, titcoin, shitcoin...”, “51 shitcoins every 2 minutes”, “lots of people will get burned along the way”. The message it replies to is about people who launch a new chain to get “a lot of the easy-to-generate-at-the-beginning-coins”. ↩
-
Satoshi Spritz, common rules of the groups, consulted on 14 November 2026: a Satoshi Spritz is not “an event in which to talk about, sponsor or promote altcoins, shitcoins, tokens or scamcoins”. ↩↩
-
Slides of the meetings Speck & Bitcoin, Hub Trento, no. 15 (“Real ‘scamcoins’ are here”), and Criptovalute, Urban Center Rovereto, no. 28 (“The real ‘scamcoins’ are here”), October 2016. ↩
-
Marco Amadori, Facebook post of 18 November 2016. The rule's asterisk reads in full: “the 0.01 is non-Bitcoin, non-scam projects that exist, but would not ask for your money through a man in a tie anyway”. ↩
-
Satoshi Nakamoto, “Bitcoin v0.1 released”, Cryptography list, 9 January 2009: “It'll be distributed to network nodes when they make blocks”; to generate some, “Options->Generate Coins”. ↩
-
Dash Core Group, “Dash Instamine Issue Clarification”, project document updated on 14 July 2020: “There was no pre-mine in Dash”; 1.99 million coins after about 34 hours, at block 4,501, “approximately 10.5% of the total money supply that will ever be issued”. ↩
-
SEC, investigative report on The DAO, 25 July 2017: the attack begins on 17 June 2016; the fork restores the investments “as if the Attack had not occurred”; the minority stays on the previous chain, “now known as ‘Ethereum Classic’”; “DAO Tokens are securities”; “All securities offered and sold in the United States must be registered”. Block and date of the fork: Ethereum Foundation, “Hard Fork Completed”, 20 July 2016. ↩↩
-
Amadori at La Miniera, 2022, min. 23. ↩
-
“Terra blockchain halted to protect against possible attack”, The Block, 12 May 2022: “Terra validators have decided to halt the Terra chain to prevent governance attacks”. ↩
-
SEC, press release 2019-202, 30 September 2019: an unregistered offering of 900 million tokens, between June 2017 and June 2018, which raised “several billion dollars”; penalty of 24 million dollars. ↩
-
The study is by Statis Group and is reported by CoinGeek on 13 July 2018: “over 80% of projects (by # share) were identified as scams”; 1.34 billion out of 11.9 to “three ‘relatively old school frauds’”. It is a secondary source: we haven't found the original report. ↩
-
SEC, press release 2024-73, 13 June 2024: “agreed to pay more than $4.5 billion following a unanimous jury verdict”; the verdict is from 5 April 2024. ↩
-
Department of Justice, US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, press release of 11 December 2025: sentence of 15 years, after the guilty plea of August 2025; the collapse caused “over $40 billion worth in investor losses”. ↩
-
FBI, press release of 30 June 2022: OneCoin “was marketed as a new virtual currency that would be the ‘Bitcoin killer’”; “OneCoin claimed to have a private blockchain”, and “investors were just asked to trust OneCoin”. ↩
-
Department of Justice, US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, press release of 25 January 2024: “the scheme took in more than $4 billion from at least 3.5 million victims”; the value was set by the company, and “The purported price of OneCoins never decreased in value”. ↩
-
Department of Justice, press release of 25 February 2022: a platform that promised “guaranteed returns” with a trading programme; “BitConnect operated as a Ponzi scheme by paying earlier BitConnect investors with money from later investors”; “approximately $2.4 billion”. ↩
-
SEC, press release 2021-172, 1 September 2021: “defrauded retail investors out of $2 billion”. ↩
-
Department of Justice, US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of California, press release of 16 September 2022: “sentenced in federal court today to 38 months in prison”. ↩
-
Slides of the meeting Criptovalute, Urban Center Rovereto, October 2016, nos. 31 and 32, “How to tell if it's a scam?”. ↩↩
-
Slides of the JETN meeting, “Fintech e territorio”, Trento, 16 November 2018, no. 32. ↩