Bitcoin Valley is dead, long live Bitcoin Valley
Since 1 July 2026 only holders of a licence under MiCAR, the EU's crypto-assets regulation, may provide bitcoin services in Italy. The Via Rialto shop could not obtain one and is closing. The Valley is not dead: it is becoming what it should always have been.
- What happened
- Since 1 July 2026, services on bitcoin may be provided in Italy only by those holding a MiCAR licence. The shop in Via Rialto could not obtain one, and on 27 November 2026 it closes.
- Why
- The licence is sized for the big platforms: for a small counter that holds nothing, it is out of scale.
- What remains
- The shops that accept bitcoin, the free software and this site. The ending is still to be written.
Digital immortality

As with kings: Bitcoin Valley is dead, long live Bitcoin Valley. But it isn't really dead: like the goliardic spirit of the anthem, it doesn't die. The counter in Via Rialto, which for nine years explained bitcoin in person, is closing, and a community is not a website or a company that can be shut down. In the Valley there are still people who accept bitcoin, people who own it and people who spend it, and there will be more and more of them. The shops remain, the people who opened them, the software anyone can run, and this site. The Valley is transforming into what it should always have been.


It was never a business. The turnover of inbitcoin and Bmanity came from elsewhere, and the Valley was the by-product everyone knew them for. That is why closing one counter doesn't switch it off.
The card is by Gabriele Ciolli, who was one of the developers of the Valley's software and today, with Rossobranco, teaches dog training in Rubano, near Padua.
The facts, in order
| When | What | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 23 May 2025 | Trento, Castello del Buonconsiglio: at the Economics Festival Paolo Savona, chairman of Consob, Italy's financial markets regulator, speaks about the European regulation his authority has to apply. Rovereto is twenty-five kilometres away. | Simply Biz1 |
| October 2025 | Figures presented in Rome by the Bank of Italy and Consob: Germany has issued 19 authorisations, the Netherlands 16, Malta 8, France 7. Italy has received 3 formal applications, only one of them under assessment. At the end of 2024 there were 166 operators on the register of the OAM, the Italian body that listed crypto firms, 150 of them legal entities. | BeBeez2 |
| December 2025 | Comproeuro, the Via Rialto shop, stops buying and selling bitcoin. To a formal query, Amadori says, the answer he gets is: “Close down or go abroad.” Months of attempts with already authorised third-party partners follow, and founder on cost or legal impossibility. | Amadori34 |
| 29 December 2025 | The European register lists more than 130 authorised entities, 36 in Germany and 22 in the Netherlands. None is Italian. | Milano Finanza5 |
| 7 May 2026 | Consob authorises the first Italian operator. | Consob6 |
| 30 June 2026 | The transition period ends. Nine are cleared to operate in Italy: eight authorised operators, two of them on that last day, and a bank that filed a notification. Anyone without authorisation in at least one EU country must stop. | The Signal Media, Consob78 |
| 6 November 2026 | il Dolomiti announces the closure: “An Italian first that pays for badly written laws, interpreted even worse.” And adds that the Bitcoin Valley experience does not end. | il Dolomiti9 |
| 27 November 2026 | Last day of opening for the Via Rialto shop. | Amadori4 |
Savona's words in Trento
“I do not want to put my seal on the legitimisation of cryptocurrencies” (our translation). And again: “I find myself in a position of conscientious objection.”1
The licences went to banks, to companies with banks among their shareholders or to bankers, and they came a year later than in the rest of Europe.4 Those who read the affair the other way, like the lawyer Valerio Lemma, argue that Italy applied the regulation in a straightforward way.5 But becoming an operator was never a simple registration. Even before MiCAR, enrolment in the OAM cost 8,300 euro,10 when for the same enrolment a money transfer firm pays between 300 and 2,400 euro, depending on how many collection points it has, and a bank less than a fifth of that. Under MiCAR you needed 20,000 euro, a sum no other European country asked for, plus annual costs never specified.
The text
Marco Amadori wrote it in the autumn of 2026, in the first person, for lawmakers. We corrected only two typos and one broken sentence. What follows is our translation from the Italian.
The Bitcoin Valley case: an Italian first and the cost of regulatory disproportion
The case The institutions MiCAR The proposals
One cannot speak about Bitcoin competently without ever having bought and spent some, since these are the two cognitive “clicks” that assist understanding of the phenomenon. In Trentino we have been doing this for more than ten years in a place around Rovereto called “Bitcoin Valley”, where since 2017 there has been a physical location, ComproEuro, which helps the curious citizen find his way through this new technological environment.
Bitcoin Valley did not come from a call for tenders or from public funding, did not cost local authorities a single euro, spread from the bottom up and got Rovereto (and Italy) talked about across half the world.
- The first Bitcoin community in Europe rooted in a territory: shopkeepers, businesses and citizens really use Bitcoin, they don't merely talk about it.
- 2013: the first business in Trentino to accept bitcoin, when almost nobody knew what it was, a barber in Cavalese.
- 2017: Satoshi Design is founded, based in Rovereto, the first company with share capital contributed in bitcoin.
- 2017: the Comproeuro shop opens in Rovereto, the first physical place in Europe to approach Bitcoin in person.
- June 2018: the first Lightning Network transaction in the world in a bar, at the Mani al Cielo in Rovereto.
Until December 2025 Comproeuro made it possible to buy and sell bitcoin without holding citizens' euros or bitcoin and, until next month, to get quality information from experts trained in the field. The result is informed citizens, in a systematic way.
Not having custody brings peace of mind, at a cost in training and knowledge, because what you do not hold you cannot lose, it cannot be stolen from you, it cannot end up in a bankruptcy. It is a protection that no law and no auditor can offer: they supervise a risk, we had removed it altogether.
When the institutions understood
Trentino's institutions noticed early, and that should be acknowledged. On 7 November 2017 the Council of the Autonomous Province of Trento approved motion no. 174 on promoting the use of bitcoin in Trentino.
The proposal by councillor Alessio Manica passed with only one vote against and four abstentions. It committed the provincial government to creating a working group with Trentino Sviluppo and the start-ups in the sector, to understand what this technology could give the territory and to test it in the field. Very cautious objectives, but achieved.
Meanwhile the experiment was already a reality. In the Vallagarina, school canteen meal vouchers could be paid for in bitcoin, with a pool of more than 11,000 students. A public service that accepts Bitcoin: there was nothing like it in Europe. Then came pagoPA [the state platform for public payments] and Trentino's exceptionalism was reabsorbed.
An ecosystem that built itself
When a territory understands Bitcoin, things start to happen by themselves.
Businesses. Other companies sprang from the first nucleus: Inbitcoin in 2016, Comproeuro as its offshoot in 2017; the fertile ground also saw the birth of Europe's largest miner, from two young people from Trento.
Shopkeepers. Those who chose to accept bitcoin, such as restaurants, petrol stations, newsstands, driving schools, hairdressers, gained new customers, learned how a new form of money works and, those who held on to it, benefited from the upward volatility of these years.
Tourism. A tourist trade took shape that no marketing office could have designed. People who moved their holidays to come and pay in bitcoin, families who moved here, Utrecht University devoted an anthropology thesis to it, carried out in the field among Rovereto's users, and Bocconi University shot a teaching documentary here.
Civic outpost. The shop was also a place people came to in order to understand. In 2018 Aaron van Wirdum, later editor of Bitcoin Magazine, told of a customer who had driven 80 kilometres just to buy bitcoin from us. All too often, too, there came people who had already been scammed by a web page or by faceless parties on WhatsApp. We were there, in Via Rialto, and we put our faces to it. No online service can replace a person who looks you in the eye and tells you: stop.
MiCAR: the right rule applied to the wrong person
Then came the interpretation of MiCAR, without proportion. From that day, services on crypto-assets may be provided only by entities authorised as CASPs. Everyone else closes.
The numbers speak for themselves. Of about 150 operators on the OAM register, only 8 have obtained CASP authorisation from Consob, in agreement with the Bank of Italy: little more than 5%. Comproeuro is not among them. Not because of any irregularity: for a neighbourhood business, the licence is simply out of scale. The costs of compliance eat up every margin before you have even opened the door to the first customer.
And here comes the paradox. To carry on I would have needed, among other things (and it would not have been enough), a custodian for funds of which I have never had custody. It is as if a baker were required to own wheat fields because the law on flour was designed for Barilla.
A rule written for large platforms, which hold billions of other people's assets in their bellies, is applied without any proportionality to a small counter that, by design, holds nothing. The citizen does not come out of it better protected. He merely loses a model that was already protecting him, and better.
With Comproeuro a physical place for understanding Bitcoin disappears. Those who pay are above all the people who do not trust going online or cannot manage it: the elderly, the less digitally literate, those who want to talk to someone in flesh and blood before choosing. Thus dies an Italian first and more than 10 years of satisfied and protected customers.
Concluding remarks
Bitcoin Valley shows that innovation can be born in a territory, can grow even with a homeopathic minimum of support from local institutions, and can produce economic, tourist and civic value. It also shows that a rule not calibrated to the principle of proportionality can switch it off in a day, without any citizen coming out better protected.
Article 5 of the Treaty on European Union establishes that regulatory action must not go beyond what is necessary to achieve its objectives. Here that principle has perhaps been lost along the way. As one who practises Bitcoin every day, I submit some concrete proposals to the legislator:
- A simplified regime, national and European, for small operators who do not hold clients' funds or crypto-assets.
- Capital and organisational requirements graduated according to actual risk, not the label on the service.
- Recognition of physical counters as outposts of technical education and of the fight against scams.
- Protection of the local experiences that have made Italy a European point of reference.
A healthy system is not one that eliminates every risk on paper. It is one that lets survive the models that have already removed the risk by construction. Bitcoin Valley anticipated the future: it would be a pity if the rule were what took it back.
Marco Amadori
The claims to being first are the author's. The ones we have been able to verify, with sources, are on the press page.
If you hold office: what another place could do again In Rovereto, meanwhile, people go on paying: come and see
-
Simply Biz, on the conversation with Marina Brogi at the Trento Economics Festival, 26 May 2025. Radiocor, 23 May 2025, reports the first sentence in slightly different words: “my seal on the legitimisation of crypto”. ↩↩
-
BeBeez, 29 October 2025, on the workshop of 22 October. ↩
-
Marco Amadori, the text on this page. ↩
-
Marco Amadori, statement to the editors, November 2026. The reply to the query is as he reports it. ↩↩↩
-
Consob statement, 7 May 2026. ↩
-
Joint statement by Consob and the Bank of Italy, 30 June 2026. ↩
-
Luca Andreazza, “Chiude Comproeuro: un primato italiano che paga leggi scritte male e interpretate peggio”, il Dolomiti, 6 November 2026. ↩
-
IPSOA, Registro OAM: fissato il contributo per l'iscrizione, 27 April 2022 (OAM circular no. 41 of 21 April 2022). ↩